How to Deal with a Toxic and Manipulative Boss at Work

You think you’re just dealing with a difficult colleague? What if it’s actually a manipulative, toxic boss — a master of psychological games at work? Here’s how to spot the signs and survive the manipulation.

Some people suck all the warmth out of a room the moment they walk in — like human black holes. They’re often labelled toxic colleagues, and when they’re your boss, it’s even worse. I met my first one during my very first student job. Let’s just say I was initiated into the corporate jungle by the Dark Side of the Force. Back then, I was too polite, too well-behaved, too eager to “understand others and not judge” to know how to handle it. The perfect prey, basically.

Day One: I Feel Like Beyoncé in a Grey Suit

My first job was in an administrative office at a university (yes, I even tried a Government job at the start). Not exactly thrilling, but I had a desk, a rolling chair, and the giddy feeling of finally being someone. I told myself: “This is it. My career begins now.”

What I didn’t know? Enthusiasm can make you the ideal target. My supervisor gave me very clear instructions:

“You process the files in THIS order. No exceptions.
Okay, boss.

Day Two: She Flips the Rules Without Warning

I come back and follow her exact instructions. She storms in like I’ve slashed her tires.
“Why on earth are you doing it THAT way?”

I mumble that I followed what she said. She denies it. Or doesn’t — but decides that today’s game is “Guess the New Rule.”

Day Three: Repeat Performance.
Day Four: Same Scene, New Twist.

Every attempt to follow orders becomes a new reason to scold me.

Spoiler Alert: It Wasn’t a Misunderstanding

At first, I thought it was me. A beginner’s mistake, maybe some confusion, stress, or just inexperience. Then I figured maybe she was just overwhelmed and giving vague instructions. But the pattern became clear: she didn’t want me to understand. The confusion was part of her method. A calculated fog, designed to keep me doubting everything — even my own reasoning.

It was a power game. And in the audience of this little cruel theater? Another intern, as young as me, watching it all unfold with a smirk. Female solidarity? It exists in glossy magazines. That day, I realized you can be complicit in manipulation without being the mastermind. And me, stuck in the role of the “nice girl,” stayed silent, convinced it was all my fault.

Breaking Point: I Burst into Tears

One day, she took it too far. I cracked. Tears streamed down my face. Of course, no one reacted. Not a glance, not a word. Just her, with a satisfied little smile. I lasted a month on a three-month contract. Not much, but it was a choice between my mental health and that so-called “professional experience.” I made my choice and never regretted it.

Before leaving, I had a tiny act of rebellion: I went to HR and calmly explained that I didn’t understand why the department even took interns, since there was literally nothing to do (which was 100% true). I knew nothing would change, but saying it out loud felt amazing. Sometimes, speaking the truth is already a way to take back power.

What I Wish I Knew at 20 About Toxic Bosses (That I Know Now)

What I experienced wasn’t a “generational misunderstanding.” It was a textbook psychological game, straight out of Transactional Analysis.

The Favorite Game of Toxic Bosses: NIGYSOB

Ugly acronym for Now I’ve Got You, Son Of a Bitch. Here’s how it works:

  1. The toxic boss sets you up — professionally or morally.
  2. You fall for it, thinking you’re just doing your job.
  3. They slam you down: “Ah! Gotcha, you incompetent fool!”

My experience was just one variation of this game. Here are others you might recognize:

  • The boss who asks for urgent work, then shames you for not using a layout they never mentioned.
  • The manager who pushes you to speak in a meeting, then tells you you’re “out of line.”
  • The client who hounds you for a quote, then accuses you of being pushy.
  • The “nice” colleague who encourages you to open up — only to report everything to your superior.

Goal of the toxic player? To trap you in a fake mistake, unload their frustrations, and still come out looking squeaky clean.

Why Do We Fall for It?

This kind of manipulation only works if we agree — often unconsciously — to operate in the fog. Because we want to do well, avoid offending, and assume the misunderstanding is ours, we stay silent. And that’s exactly when the trap springs shut.

That unspoken vagueness becomes their perfect playground. As long as you don’t question it, you’re playing the game. And as long as you’re playing, you’re losing.

How to Break the Game: 4 Techniques That Work

These manipulations can be subtle. But here’s how to hit pause — without losing your dignity.

1. The Clarifying Email

Example:
“Hi, just confirming — you want me to process the files in reverse alphabetical order starting today? Should I begin now?”

This sets the rules in writing, puts you in a clear adult role, and forces the toxic boss to commit.

2. The Extra Eyes

If others are involved, copy someone else in:
“Since several people are concerned, I’ll CC Aline so we’re all aligned. Okay with you?”

This makes the situation more visible and harder to manipulate.

3. Public Reformulation

In a meeting, clearly rephrase the instruction:
“Just to confirm, what you’re asking is X — is that correct for everyone?”

If the toxic person hesitates or backpedals, the manipulation becomes obvious.

4. The Anti-Bait Response

Stay calm, don’t react emotionally:
“Thanks for the feedback. I’ll take some time to consider the best approach.”

This helps you keep control — without playing into their guilt trip.

What Happens When You Break the Cycle

Once you stop playing, the toxic boss will react. If they accept your clarification, you’re probably dealing with a difficult person, not a manipulative one — a resolution might be possible.

But if they flip out (“Are you accusing me of lying?!”), you’ve broken their control. Then it’s one of two outcomes: either they calm down and the cycle ends, or they try to isolate you and find a new target.

Either way, you’re no longer in their game. They might try to quietly undermine your credibility — but hold your ground, clarify expectations, and stand firm to neutralize their tactics.

When Leaving Is the Only Way Out

Leaving toxic boss management

Some toxic bosses — especially those with narcissistic tendencies — don’t just play games. They rule over entire departments, influencing dynamics and draining the life out of teams. Their power thrives in silence, propped up by passive bystanders. The result? Sick leave, burnout, depression — and occupational health services left to clean up the mess.

Sometimes the only real solution is to walk away — before the poison eats away at your emotions, your mental health, your identity.

What I experienced was a form of gaslighting — that subtle manipulation that makes you question your own reality. If that rings a bell, read this article about gaslighting at work.

Take Back Control: Get Out of the Trap

With time, I learned to spot the games, to ask the kind of questions that freeze manipulation in its tracks, to stop playing by default. And it changed everything. Did I still run into toxic people? Of course. But somehow, they lost interest in me. Maybe I’d learned how to bite back politely — or made it clear I’d read the manual.

If you’ve been through something similar — or seen it happen around you — know this:
The problem is the game and those who insist on playing it. But you? You have a choice.

  • Clarify expectations at the first hint of vagueness.
  • Spot the psychological patterns.
  • And if it stays toxic? Set boundaries — or leave before it breaks you.

It takes courage, yes. But here’s the thing:

You already have that courage.
So keep your head up. And remember: the real victory is the freedom, not to play by their rules!

For a deeper understanding of the warning signs that signal a toxic work environment—and how to protect yourself—check out our comprehensive guide on recognizing the signs of a toxic workplace.

Scroll to Top